Supreme Court Says No Voter Has Vested Right To Reserved Constituency, Upholds Maharashtra Rotation Rule

5 min read

“Do you have a right to have your constituency reserved? No.” With that remark from the Bench, the Supreme Court dismissed a challenge to Maharashtra’s rotation rule, holding that no voter has a vested right to a Reserved Constituency.

Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana of the Supreme Court of India, who held no voter has a vested right to a reserved constituency.

New Delhi: Holding that the manner and timing of rotation of reserved seats is a matter for the State Government, the Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, dismissed a special leave petition challenging Rule 12 of the Maharashtra Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis (Manner and Rotation of Reservation of Seats) Rules, 2025. The Court ruled that no voter or candidate has a vested right to have a particular constituency reserved for Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes [Sau. Rupali Indrabhushan Sonde @ Ku. Rupali Sharadrao Badhiye v. State of Maharashtra].

The order was dictated by a Bench of Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, after Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi appeared for the petitioner.

No vested right to a particular seat

The Bench accepted that the argument had some surface appeal, but found that it overlooked a basic point. In its dictated order, it held:

“Though the argument is attractive at the first blush, the same fails to take into consideration that no voter or candidate can have a vested right to have a particular constituency reserved. What the Constitution and 1961 Rules prescribe is a proportionate reservation of seats vis-a-vis the proportion of SC/ST in the total population of the local body concerned.”

The Rules do prescribe rotation of reserved seats in descending order of SC/ST population, the Court accepted. But the manner and the time frame of that reservation and rotation lie within the discretion of the government, which exercised it by making the next election after the 2025 amendment the first election for the purpose.

“We find no reason to hold that said Rule runs counter to either the concept of reservation of rotation of seats. Dismissed. Needless to mention, dismissal of the petition shall not stand in the way of the petitioner’s representation for reconsideration of the scheme of rotation of reserved seats as per law.”

What Rule 12 does, and why it was challenged

Rule 12 treats the next election held after the 2025 amendment as the first election for the purpose of rotation, which in effect resets the rotation cycle. The petitioner had first gone to the Bombay High Court, asking that the Rule be struck down as violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

That petition failed. The High Court held that no person could claim a right of reservation to a particular seat, and noted that population percentages had changed since the last census. It observed:

“In this regard, it is necessary to mention here that the State Government for the first time has decided to change the areas of constituencies and therefore, the new constituencies would definitely get changed on the basis of geographical limits. Consequently, reservation of seat would also be changed. Therefore, as on today, it cannot be said that whether particular area would be reserved for particular category or not. The guesswork which the petitioners have done is not the ground to declare Rule (XII) as contrary to the Constitution or arbitrary on its face.”

Rotation “made illusory”, and the Bench’s reply

In the Supreme Court, Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi argued that Rule 12 rendered the concept of rotation illusory. His client’s constituency, where the SC/ST population percentage is low, had never been reserved, he said, and just when its turn came, the authorities announced that the process would start afresh.

Clarifying that he was not pressing the validity of the Rule as such, Sanghi submitted:

“They have played fraud. I am in a constituency where percentage is low. This has never been reserved. When my turn to be reserved comes, they say we will start afresh. Which means that this constituency would never get reservation.”

Justice Bagchi pointed out that the Constitution and the 1961 Rules speak of rotation, but leave its mechanism to the State Government, and that Rule 12 falls within that jurisdiction. He remarked:

“Do you have a right to have your constituency reserved? No. It is the cutoff date. It can always be shifted by the government.”

Why the order matters

Rotation of reserved seats is meant to spread representation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes across constituencies over successive elections. Each time a State redraws constituencies or resets the cycle, some areas that were next in line lose their expected turn. The order makes clear that such an expectation is not an enforceable right, and that courts will not interfere with a State’s choice of cut-off date so long as reservation remains proportionate to population.

With Maharashtra’s rural local body elections being held on freshly drawn constituencies, the ruling closes one line of challenge to the 2025 rotation scheme, while leaving the petitioner free to seek reconsideration from the State through a representation.

Case Title: Sau. Rupali Indrabhushan Sonde @ Ku. Rupali Sharadrao Badhiye v. The State of Maharashtra
Case Number: Diary No. 68024/2026
Bench: Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, Supreme Court of India
Date of Order: November 16, 2026
Appearances: Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi, with AoR Anagha S Desai, for the petitioner

Similar Posts