Security organisations need systems for periodic mental health checks of personnel entrusted with firearms, the Karnataka High Court has said, while discharging a CISF Sub-Inspector from a 2022 case of attempted suicide under the now-repealed Section 309 of the IPC.

Bengaluru: A Mangaluru magistrate refused to discharge a Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) Sub-Inspector prosecuted for attempting suicide, without weighing the statutory presumption of severe stress under Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017. The Karnataka High Court has now set that refusal aside. The Court also said that police and other armed security organisations must assess the mental health of personnel before entrusting them with firearms and periodically thereafter [Jyoti Bai v. State of Karnataka].
Justice Suraj Govindaraj passed the order on November 12, 2026, in a criminal petition filed under Section 482 of the CrPC read with Section 528 of the BNSS.
What the Court decided
The Court allowed the criminal petition, set aside the magistrate’s order of December 26, 2024, allowed the discharge application, and discharged the petitioner from the offence under Section 309 of the IPC in CC No. 2422 of 2023.
It also directed:
“The Registry shall forward a copy of this order to the Director General, CISF; the Director General of Police, Karnataka; and the heads of other State organisations having personnel entrusted with firearms, for their information and consideration.”
Those who protect others have limits too
The responsibility of a security organisation, the Court said, does not end with assigning duties to its personnel. Those who protect others experience grief, anxiety, financial strain and personal difficulties like anyone else, and the expectation that they remain available at all times regardless of their state of mind needs a rethink. The Court observed:
“Personnel must have an environment in which they can seek assistance without stigma or fear of adverse consequences. Their need for counselling, treatment, family support, rest or temporary relief from particular duties must be recognised and addressed.”
Linking mental health with operational readiness and public safety, the Court said:
“At the same time, mental health is directly connected with operational readiness and public safety, particularly in the case of personnel entrusted with firearms. The authorities must have appropriate systems for assessing the mental health and fitness of such personnel, both before entrusting firearms and periodically thereafter, with provision for reassessment whenever circumstances so warrant. Suitable procedures must also exist for regulating access to firearms where a genuine safety concern arises, while ensuring that such preventive measures do not become punitive or result in automatic exclusion from service.”
Organisations, the Court added, must provide accessible and confidential counselling and professional mental health care to personnel of the armed forces, police and other security organisations, and discipline and dedication cannot be demanded at the cost of ignoring basic human needs.
The petitioner and the magistrate’s refusal
The petitioner, a Sub-Inspector posted with the CISF unit at New Mangalore Port, was booked by the Panambur police in 2022 under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code after an attempt to end her life. Her counsel told the Court that she had been under severe personal stress at the time. She also faced departmental proceedings, which ended in a major penalty of a lifetime reduction by one stage of pay and denial of promotion for five years.
Her application for discharge under Section 239 of the CrPC read with Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act was rejected on December 26, 2024 by the Judicial Magistrate First Class II, Mangalore, in Criminal Case No. 2422 of 2023. She challenged that order before the High Court.
The presumption the magistrate did not consider
Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act presumes that a person who attempts suicide was under severe stress, and says such a person shall not be tried and punished under Section 309 of the IPC unless the contrary is proved. The High Court found that the magistrate had failed to consider this presumption while refusing discharge, and said the law treats such a person as someone who needs care rather than punishment:
“The legislative approach is to treat such a person as one in need of care, treatment and rehabilitation, rather than penal sanctions.”
Why the judgment matters
Section 309 of the IPC stayed on the statute book until the IPC was repealed, but Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act had already turned the default position around: a person who attempts suicide is presumed to have been under severe stress and is not to be tried unless the prosecution proves otherwise. The ruling reminds trial courts that this presumption must be applied at the discharge stage, and that a prosecution of this kind cannot continue without it being addressed.
The judgment also goes beyond the individual case. By asking security organisations to screen personnel before issuing firearms, reassess them periodically, and offer confidential care without making it a ground for punishment or automatic exclusion, the Court has framed mental health as part of operational safety. The copy sent to the CISF and Karnataka Police chiefs is for their consideration, so how far these suggestions are adopted rests with the forces concerned.
Case Title: Jyoti Bai v. State of Karnataka [Criminal Petition No. 8281 of 2025 (482 Cr.PC / 528 BNSS)], NC: 2026:KHC:62699
Bench: Justice Suraj Govindaraj, Karnataka High Court
Date of Order: November 12, 2026
Appearances: Advocate Tarunn Surana for the petitioner; High Court Government Pleader Ranjith Kumar for the State
If you or someone you know is struggling, please reach out to Tele-MANAS, the Government of India’s free 24×7 mental health helpline, at 14416 or 1-800-891-4416.
