Calcutta High Court Sets Aside SBI Manager’s Discharge In Rs 165 Crore Fraud, Faults Mini-Trial

4 min read

An SBI manager’s discharge in a CBI case over an alleged Rs 164.99 crore loss to the bank has been set aside by the Calcutta High Court, which held that the special court sifted evidence at a stage meant only to test for grave suspicion.

Justice Uday Kumar of the Calcutta High Court, who set aside the SBI manager’s discharge in a Rs 165 crore CBI fraud case.

Kolkata: A special court should not have weighed witness statements and audit nuances before framing charges, the Calcutta High Court has ruled while allowing a revision petition by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). The High Court set aside the 2022 order discharging Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo, Chief Manager and Relationship Manager at a State Bank of India branch, from a case over the alleged misappropriation of more than Rs 164.99 crore, and directed the trial court to frame charges against him [Central Bureau of Investigation v. Shri Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo].

Justice Uday Kumar delivered the judgment on November 12, 2026, in CRR 4653 of 2022, after reserving it on October 14.

A premature sifting of evidence

Justice Uday Kumar found that the special court had gone well beyond its role under Section 239 CrPC by weighing witness statements, reading internal audit nuances and assessing the evidentiary value of departmental warnings before trial:

“This Court has conclusively established that the learned trial court committed a fundamental jurisdictional error by embarking upon a premature, exhaustive marshalling and sifting of evidence at the threshold stage of Section 239 CrPC.”

On the material itself, the High Court held that it raised grave suspicion against Kanungo, which was enough at the stage of framing charges:

“They establish a strong and grave suspicion of active complicity, criminal conspiracy, cheating, and abuse of official position against the Opposite Party under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.”

The Court added that the discharge order suffered from “foundational legal infirmities” and “a perversity of approach in evaluating defence explanations at the pre-charge stage”, omitted substantive incriminating material, and created “an unsustainable legal anomaly that severs the insider public servant from the overarching criminal conspiracy involving private borrowers”.

What the CBI says happened at the bank

The agency challenged Order No. 26 dated September 29, 2022, passed by the Special Judge, CBI Court No. 2, Calcutta, in Special (CBI) Case No. 02/22, which arose out of FIR No. RCBSK 2017E0001 dated March 28, 2017. The special court had discharged Kanungo, arrayed as Accused No. 3.

According to the CBI, public money was siphoned off from SBI through unauthorised accounts, unbacked inter-company fund shuffles and monthly reports that concealed large overdue amounts. The agency alleges that Kanungo helped M/s Shree Mahalaxmi Corporation Private Limited (SMCPL) fraudulently secure large credit facilities, causing a loss of over Rs 164.99 crore to the bank.

Routine lapses or active facilitation

Special Public Prosecutor Amajit De, for the CBI, relied on documentary evidence, audit trails and logs, and argued that the financial discrepancies were not routine administrative lapses but showed that Kanungo acted as an active, conscious internal facilitator of the alleged fraud.

Kanungo’s counsel argued that he had no prior link with, or motive to conspire with, the borrower company, and that every credit appraisal and restructuring proposal he processed followed institutional guidelines and was supervised and countersigned by several senior bank executives, including the Deputy General Manager.

Charges to follow

The High Court allowed the revision, set aside and quashed the September 29, 2022 discharge order, and remanded the matter with a direction to restore Special (CBI) Case No. 02/22 to its file against Kanungo. Upon formal submission of the prosecution sanction order, if awaited, or otherwise in accordance with law, the trial court is to frame charges against him under the appropriate provisions of the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and try him jointly with the remaining co-accused. Interim orders were vacated, and there was no order as to costs.

The allegations against Kanungo are yet to be tested at trial. The High Court’s findings relate only to the threshold of framing charges, and he is entitled to the presumption of innocence.

Why the judgment matters

The ruling restates a settled limit on discharge proceedings: at the stage of Sections 227 and 239 CrPC, a court only asks whether the material raises grave suspicion against the accused. It cannot weigh competing explanations or test the reliability of evidence, which is the work of a full trial.

It is also significant for bank fraud prosecutions, where officials often argue that their decisions were countersigned by seniors and followed internal procedure. The Court made clear that such defences are matters for trial and cannot be used to separate a public servant from an alleged conspiracy with private borrowers at the threshold.

Case Title: Central Bureau of Investigation v. Shri Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo [CRR 4653 of 2022]
Bench: Justice Uday Kumar, Calcutta High Court
Reserved on: October 14, 2026
Date of Judgment: November 12, 2026
Appearances: Amajit De, Special Public Prosecutor, for the CBI; Advocates Aritra Bhattacharya, Saptarshi Basu and Suman Dutta for the opposite party

Similar Posts