Notable Judgments By Justice Yashwant Varma: Delhi High Court

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

Justice Yashwant Varma of the Delhi High Court has delivered notable judgments shaping Indian jurisprudence on taxation, media freedom, and corporate disputes.

Notable Judgments by Justice Yashwant Varma | Delhi High Court

Justice Yashwant Varma has delivered several landmark rulings during his tenure at the Delhi High Court and Allahabad High Court. His judgments span crucial areas of law, including taxation, intellectual property, firearms regulations, and constitutional rights. Here are some of his significant legal pronouncements:

CLICK HERE TO WATCH VIDEO OF CASH FOUND AT JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA’S HOME

Gold Imports Under Customs Act (2023)

Case Summary: Justice Varma, leading a division bench, ruled that gold is a ‘prohibited item’ for import under the Customs Act, 1962.
Key Ruling: The judgment clarified that the term “prohibition” under the Act includes goods that are regulated or restricted, such as gold imports.
Impact: This decision had a significant influence on India’s gold import policies and customs regulations.
Case title: Nidhi Kapoor v. Principal Commissioner and Additional Secretary to the Government of India (2023)

Copyright of Satyajit Ray’s ‘Nayak’ (2023)

Case Summary: Justice Varma upheld a ruling that legendary filmmaker Satyajit Ray was the original copyright owner of his 1966 classic film Nayak.
Key Ruling: The decision came amid an appeal seeking to block the publication of a novel based on the film’s script.
Impact: This landmark ruling reinforced copyright protections for filmmakers and creative artists.
Case Title: RDB and Co. HUF v. HarperCollins Publishers India Pvt. Ltd. (2023)

Arms Act Clarification (2022)

Case Summary: The court addressed a crucial interpretation of the Arms Act, 1959, regarding licensed firearm ownership.
Key Ruling: Justice Varma ruled that even members of Rifles Associations or Clubs are limited to owning a maximum of two firearms.
Impact: The decision reaffirmed that the right to possess firearms is not an absolute constitutional right under Indian law.
Case Title: Meet Malhotra vs. Union of India & Ors (2021)

Bail to Dr. Kafeel Khan (2018)

Case Summary: During his tenure at the Allahabad High Court, Justice Varma granted bail to Dr. Kafeel Khan, who was accused of medical negligence following the 2017 Gorakhpur hospital tragedy.
Key Ruling: The court found no direct evidence implicating Khan in the oxygen supply crisis that led to multiple child fatalities.
Impact: This ruling drew national attention to issues of medical accountability, government negligence, and human rights.
Case Title: Dr. Kafeel Khan v. State of Uttar Pradesh All HC (2018)

ALSO READ: Judge Caught With Crores | Amit Malviya Slams Justice Yashwant Varma’s Ruling On Shibu Soren’s Corruption Probe

Income Tax Reassessment Proceedings Against Indian National Congress

Case Summary: A Division Bench led by Justice Varma dismissed multiple petitions by the Congress Party, allowing scrutiny of its income by the Income Tax Department.
Key Ruling: The court observed that the IT Department had substantial and concrete evidence justifying further investigation.
Impact: This ruling underscored financial accountability and tax compliance for political parties.
Case Title: Income Tax Reassessment Proceedings Against Indian National Congress (2024)

PayPal Reporting Entity Obligation Under PMLA

Case Summary: Justice Varma ruled that PayPal qualifies as a ‘payment system operator’ under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).
Key Ruling: The judgment mandated PayPal to comply with Section 12 of PMLA, which requires financial platforms to maintain transaction records and client identities for ten years.
Impact: This decision reinforced India’s financial transparency and anti-money laundering framework.
Case Title: Paypal Payments Private Limited vs Financial Intelligence Unit India & Anr(2024)

ALSO READ : Corruption Within Judiciary | Room Filled with Unaccounted Cash at Delhi High Court Judge’s Home: CJI Takes Immediate Strict Action

Powers of Enforcement Directorate (ED)

Case Summary: The court examined the scope of the Enforcement Directorate’s (ED) investigative authority.
Key Ruling: Justice Varma held that the ED cannot investigate offences beyond money laundering and cannot assume the existence of a predicate offence.
Impact: This ruling provided clarity on ED’s jurisdictional limits and prevented misuse of investigative powers.

Media Reporting of Delhi Excise Policy Case

Case Summary: Justice Varma addressed concerns over media misreporting in the Delhi Excise Policy case.
Key Ruling: The court issued notices to Republic TV, India Today, Zee News, and Times Now, directing them to ensure reporting aligns with official CBI and ED press releases.
Impact: This judgment emphasized the importance of responsible journalism in high-profile legal cases.

Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) and Right to Information

Case Summary: The court ruled on the disclosure of documents relied upon for granting prosecution sanctions under UAPA.
Key Ruling: Justice Varma held that such disclosures can be exempt under Section 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act, citing national security concerns.
Impact: This decision balanced transparency with national security in counterterrorism laws.

Judicial Bias and Fair Trial

Case Summary: Justice Varma examined the test for judicial bias in cases of alleged unfair trial proceedings.
Key Ruling: He held that judicial bias need not be proven as a fact but must be evaluated from the viewpoint of a reasonable person’s apprehension.
Impact: This ruling reinforced impartiality and public trust in the judiciary.
Case Title: Kinri Dhir v. Veer Singh(2022)

Justice Yashwant Varma’s judgments have played a pivotal role in shaping Indian legal jurisprudence in areas such as trade regulations, intellectual property rights, financial accountability, arms control, and constitutional freedoms. His rulings continue to influence ongoing debates on these critical issues.