Despite more girls receiving education, early marriages and motherhood remain common. When marriages fail, many young women face financial challenges due to lack of independence. There is growing concern regarding how income tax laws treat alimony and maintenance payments, with questions arising about possible tax exemptions on such amounts.
NEW DELHI : While more girls are getting educated nowadays, the reality is that many girls still get married at an early age and have children before they are ready. In some cases, marriages may not work out due to various reasons, leaving young women in a difficult situation. Often, they are not financially independent, which makes it harder for them to cope with the challenges they face after a separation or divorce.
Many people are also interested in understanding how income tax laws treat the amount received as maintenance or alimony in the case of separation or divorce. There have been rising concerns around Alimony and Maintenence and the tax treatment of the amount paid.
There have also , been queries around, whether there is a tax exemption of the amount or not ?
WHAT IS ALIMONY?
Alimony, also called spousal maintenance in some places, refers to the financial support that a court orders one spouse to pay to the other after a separation or divorce. This is usually done to help the spouse who earns less, or in some cases, has no income at all. Alimony ensures that the lower-earning spouse can maintain a reasonable standard of living after the divorce.
In many traditional marriages, the husband is often the main earner while the wife may have given up her career to take care of the children. This creates a situation where, after a divorce or separation, the wife may struggle financially because she doesn’t have the same earning capacity.
In such cases, alimony is intended to bridge the gap and ensure that the spouse who may not have the same income can still live a comfortable life. “The laws in many states dictate that a divorced spouse has the right to live the same quality of life they previously had when married.”
Alimony can be awarded to either the husband or the wife, depending on who needs the support after the divorce. It’s important to note that alimony rules and the amount of support vary in different places, as they are based on state laws.
RIGHT TO CLAIM ALIMONY
One of the most important rights a person has under divorce and matrimonial laws is the right to claim alimony, also known as maintenance. Alimony refers to the financial support that a court orders one spouse, usually the husband, to pay to the other spouse, typically the wife, to help her maintain her standard of living after a divorce or separation.
The court’s decision on alimony is based on the need for financial support, especially if the wife is unable to support herself.
The courts have ruled that an abandoned wife and children are entitled to “maintenance” from the date they file an application in a court of law. This means that if a wife is abandoned by her husband or if the marriage ends in divorce, she has the legal right to claim alimony from the time she applies for it in court. This financial support is meant to help her take care of herself and, if applicable, her children after the separation.
Alimony is an essential right for women who may not have the means to support themselves after a divorce, particularly if they were dependent on their husbands during the marriage.
The law aims to protect the financial well-being of individuals who may face distress due to a marriage that has ended, ensuring that they are not left in a vulnerable position.
REASONABLE NEEDS OF A WIFE AND DEPENDENT CHILDREN
In the case of Rajnesh v. Neha & Anr., the Supreme Court, in a ruling dated 4th November 2020, provided clear guidelines regarding alimony cases. One of the key points discussed was the “reasonable needs” of a wife and dependent children.
The court took into account factors such as the wife’s educational qualifications and whether she has an independent source of income. The ruling emphasized that while women can claim alimony under various laws, such as the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, Section 125 of the CrPC, or the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, it would not be fair to ask the husband to pay maintenance under multiple legal proceedings at the same time.
The court urged family and civil courts to consider any previous settlements when deciding on maintenance claims.
The Hindu Adoptions & Maintenance Act, 1956 (HAMA), also covers maintenance for dependents. Section 22 of this Act provides for the maintenance of dependents, including wives, children, and elderly or sick parents. Section 23 of the Act further explains that when determining the amount of maintenance, the court will consider several factors.
These include:
(a) the position and status of the parties involved,
(b) the “reasonable wants” of the person seeking maintenance,
(c) whether the person seeking maintenance is justified in living separately,
(d) the value of the person’s property and any income from it, or from their own earnings, and
(e) the number of people entitled to maintenance.
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN PERMANENT ALIMONY AND MAINTENANCE
The concept of permanent alimony and maintenance refers to long-term financial support that one spouse may be required to pay to the other after a divorce or separation.
However, the rules regarding who can claim alimony and under what circumstances can differ depending on the community and the laws they follow.
For instance, under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, both the husband and wife have the legal right to claim permanent alimony and maintenance if the marriage ends. On the other hand, under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, only the wife is entitled to claim permanent alimony and maintenance after divorce.
This difference in legal rights highlights that alimony and maintenance laws can vary based on the personal laws governing the marriage. In the case of the Hindu Marriage Act, both spouses are allowed to claim support from the other if they are financially dependent after the separation.
But under the Special Marriage Act, it is specifically the wife who can ask for permanent support, ensuring her financial security in case the marriage is dissolved.
DIVORCE BY MUTUAL CONSENT
Divorce by mutual consent happens when both partners agree to end their marriage amicably. In such cases, the payment of alimony or maintenance can be decided by mutual understanding between the husband and wife.
Either the husband or the wife may pay alimony, depending on what the couple agrees upon. The court will pass a decree of divorce based on the terms agreed between the couple, and this decree is binding. The couple must follow it, and if any party fails to do so, the court can enforce the decree.
However, when the divorce is contested, meaning the couple does not agree on the terms of the divorce, the court steps in and decides the matter of alimony or maintenance. In these cases, the court has the power to grant alimony to the wife even if the husband is the one being granted the divorce decree. The amount of permanent alimony is entirely at the court’s discretion, meaning the court will decide what is fair based on the specifics of the case.
WHERE WIFE REMARRIES
If the wife remarries, the husband’s responsibility to pay alimony is removed. He can petition the court to stop the alimony payments.
Similarly, if there is a change in circumstances, such as the husband going through a financial crisis or the wife becoming financially independent and earning a good salary, the husband can ask the court to review the alimony order. In these cases, the court will look at the new facts, evidence, and circumstances before deciding whether to change the amount of alimony.
The court may modify, vary, or even cancel the alimony order based on the new situation.
LUMP-SUM ALIMONY
Lump-sum alimony is another type of maintenance that can be awarded by the court. The court decides whether alimony should be paid in a lump sum or in periodic installments. If the husband’s income increases after the alimony has been awarded, the wife receiving alimony can petition the court for an increase in the amount she receives.
However, she will have to show that she is unable to support herself with the current amount of alimony. The court will take into account the facts, evidence, and circumstances of the case to decide whether the alimony should be increased.
“However, just because his income goes up does not necessarily mean she will get more alimony.”
TAXABILITY OF ALIMONY AND MAINTAINENCE
A common question that arises after a divorce is whether alimony and maintenance payments received from a spouse are taxable. The Income Tax Act of India does not specifically mention alimony, so it is necessary to refer to analogous provisions and relevant case laws to determine how such payments are treated. In the case of divorce, the relationship between the husband and wife is legally terminated, meaning they are no longer considered spouses.
In India, the law mandates that a husband has an obligation to maintain his wife, which arises from the marital relationship. The right to maintenance is governed by personal laws. According to the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973, the right to maintenance extends not just to the wife and dependent children but also to indigent parents and divorced wives.
Therefore, upon divorce, the wife may give up her personal right to claim monthly maintenance as per the law. This relinquishment of her right to claim maintenance is seen as the wife’s consideration for receiving alimony. As a result, the alimony or maintenance paid is not considered a gift, as it is in exchange for the wife’s relinquishment of her right.
In the case of CIT v. Shaw Wallace and Co, the Privy Council ruled that the Indian tax law focuses on taxing “income,” and the payments made as alimony or maintenance after divorce are considered under this framework. Therefore, it is important to understand that while maintenance payments are generally not treated as taxable income, the specific tax treatment may depend on the context and the legal provisions applied.
In the context of taxation, ‘Income’ refers to a consistent and regular monetary return from a specific source, which is expected to yield a predictable income stream. This return does not necessarily have to come from a source that continuously produces profits, but it should be derived from a source whose aim is to provide a definite return, excluding any unpredictable windfalls. To illustrate, income has often been compared to the fruit of a tree or the crop of a field, where there is a natural and expected output.
MONTHLY ALIMONY PAYMENTS
When it comes to monthly alimony payments, the Bombay High Court has ruled that alimony is an extension of the husband’s legal duty under Hindu law to support his wife.
The court further clarified that for any income to be taxable, there must be a clear source. In this case, the source is the court decree. Because alimony payments are a regular, periodic payment made as part of a legal order, the court held that such payments must be considered as income for tax purposes. Therefore, monthly alimony payments are treated as income in the hands of the recipient.
LUMP-SUM PAYMENTS
On the other hand, lump-sum alimony payments are treated differently. In a ruling, the Bombay High Court explained that lump-sum alimony should not be seen as a commutation of future monthly payments. The court pointed out that a lump sum received in the form of alimony is not taxable because it represents a settlement of the wife’s right to maintenance as a capital asset, rather than a regular income. The case law also highlights this distinction:
“the decree must be regarded as a transaction in which the right of the assessee to get maintenance from her ex-husband was recognized and given effect to. That right was undoubtedly a capital asset.”
This ruling was reinforced in the ACIT v. Meenakshi Khanna (2013) case, where the Tribunal ruled that
“A lump-sum payment made as part of a divorce agreement is not taxable in the hands of the recipient, even if it was delayed”
Similarly, the Shrimati Roma Sengupta v. CIT (Cal) case concluded that
“A lump-sum alimony is considered a capital receipt and therefore is not taxable.”
Other cases, such as Prema G. Sanghvi v. ITO (ITAT Mumbai), also support this view, stating that
“Receiving alimony from an ex-husband is treated as a gift, making it exempt from taxation”
However, where there is no divorce between the parties and an asset is transferred by one spouse to another for inadequate consideration, such a transfer is treated as a gift. Under section 56(2) of the Income Tax Act, this gift is exempt from taxation. Any income generated from this asset, however, will be included in the hands of the transferring spouse, as if the asset had not been transferred.
In summary, while monthly alimony payments are taxable as income, lump-sum alimony payments are not. It is important to understand the distinction between these two types of alimony to know how they will be treated under Indian tax law.
READ MORE INFORMATION ON DIVORCE
FOLLOW US ON YOUTUBE FOR MORE LEGAL UPDATES