An FIR that gives no date for the incident, draws a far-fetched link to an earlier kidnapping and surfaces in the middle of an ancestral property feud cannot sustain a criminal prosecution, the Patna High Court has held, quashing a Magistrate’s cognizance order that it called mechanical.

Patna: The Patna High Court has quashed the order dated August 1, 2022 of the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate-IV, Patna City taking cognizance of offences under Sections 448, 341, 323 and 506 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code against Sushil Jhunjhunwala and Rishabh Jhunjhunwala, together with the entire proceedings in Chowk P.S. Case No. 109 of 2019 [Sushil Jhunjhunwala and Another v. State of Bihar and Another].
Justice Soni Shrivastava, in a judgment delivered on September 30, 2026 after reserving it on September 24, allowed the petitioners’ application, noting that the FIR was lodged in the backdrop of a civil dispute over ancestral property and was marked by vagueness and absurdity of allegations.
Background of the case
The informant, Kiran Devi Jhunjhunwala, alleged that after her husband, Gajanandji Jhunjhunwala, was kidnapped, persons were repeatedly demanding money from her and sending their staff to her house in the evenings. She alleged that on a Saturday evening the petitioners came to her house demanding Rs 2,11,354, said to be due from her husband, and when she said she could not pay, threatened to kill her and other surviving members of her family and assaulted her with fists, until her mother-in-law intervened.
The FIR was registered on March 8, 2019 and cognizance was taken on August 1, 2022. The proceedings have not moved beyond cognizance, as they were stayed by the High Court on October 7, 2024. The Court noted that, despite notice and valid service, no one appeared for the informant. The allegations are yet to be tested at trial.
What the parties argued
Advocates Amit Narayan, Jeetendra Narayan and Abhishek Kumar, for the petitioners, argued that the parties are agnates in a dispute over ancestral property and that the informant had suppressed that relationship. They pointed to a counter FIR, Chowk P.S. Case No. 143 of 2019, lodged on March 29, 2019 by Sushil Jhunjhunwala, which they said reflected pressure on the petitioners to register the ancestral property in the names of the informant’s daughters, son-in-law and brother-in-law, and to earlier affidavited representations to the police. They said the allegations did not disclose the date of the incident or who made the demands, that the High Court’s orders in a habeas corpus petition filed by the informant did not show the petitioners’ involvement in the kidnapping, and that the cognizance order was passed mechanically. They relied on State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Judicial Magistrate and Inder Mohan Goswami v. State of Uttaranchal.
Rana Randhir Singh, the Additional Public Prosecutor, opposed the application, submitting that at the stage of cognizance only a prima facie case has to be seen and that the allegations made one out.
Vague, belated and inconsistent FIR
The Court found the narration in the FIR vague and unclear, with no date of occurrence, no details of who demanded money from the informant and when, and a link to the earlier kidnapping case that it called absurd. It observed that the FIR only mentions a Saturday, while it was lodged on March 8, 2019, a Friday, which suggests it was lodged after about six days, the earlier Saturday being March 2, 2019, so that it suffers not only from delay but from absolute vagueness as to date, time and the nature of the allegations.
The Court accepted that the parties are agnates in a dispute over ancestral property, as supported by the counter FIR, and said that against that background the allegations did not appear convincing at all. It also held that the ingredients of the offences were not made out even on the face of the FIR. No hurt, as contemplated under Section 323, was disclosed at any point, and since the case was that the petitioners came to the informant’s house there was no question of wrongful restraint, which under Section 339 means obstruction of a person from proceeding in a direction in which she has a right to proceed. The Court added that house-trespass and wrongful restraint would in most cases be mutually exclusive, and described the other allegations as purely ornamental.
Mechanical cognizance order
Relying on Pepsi Foods, which holds that summoning an accused is a serious matter and the Magistrate’s order must reflect application of mind, the Court held:
“The impugned order taking cognizance of the alleged offences also does not reflect application of judicial mind and is more in the nature of a mechanical order without looking into the vagueness and absurdity of the FIR itself.”
Bhajan Lal categories and the duty to read between the lines
The Court held that the case fell within categories 1, 5 and 7 of the Bhajan Lal guidelines, namely allegations that do not prima facie constitute an offence even if taken at face value, allegations so absurd and inherently improbable that no prudent person could find sufficient ground to proceed, and proceedings manifestly attended with mala fide and instituted with an ulterior motive to wreak vengeance out of private grudge. It also relied on Salib @ Shalu @ Salim v. State of U.P., where the Supreme Court said that in a frivolous or vexatious proceeding the High Court must look closely at the FIR and, if need be, read between the lines and take into account the overall circumstances and the materials collected in investigation, and not merely its averments. It concluded:
“…the present FIR has come to be lodged in the backdrop of a civil dispute relating to ancestral property and the FIR itself is manifested with vagueness, absurdity of allegations and is apparently attended with malafide.”
Directions
The Court allowed the application and quashed the August 1, 2022 order taking cognizance and the entire proceedings arising from Chowk P.S. Case No. 109 of 2019. It made no finding on the underlying property dispute between the parties.
Case Title: Sushil Jhunjhunwala and Another v. State of Bihar and Another
Case Number: Criminal Miscellaneous No. 70967 of 2024, arising out of Chowk P.S. Case No. 109 of 2019
Bench: Justice Soni Shrivastava, Patna High Court
Date of Judgment: September 30, 2026
Appearance: Advocates Amit Narayan, Jeetendra Narayan and Abhishek Kumar for the petitioners; Rana Randhir Singh, APP for the State; no appearance for Opposite Party No. 2 despite service
