The Supreme Court of India ruled that a husband’s decree for restitution of conjugal rights does not exempt him from paying maintenance if his wife refuses to return home. Each case must be assessed individually, and valid reasons for refusal, such as mistreatment, justify claims for maintenance, which the Supreme Court upheld in a recent case.
The Allahabad High Court rejected a husband’s claim that his wife’s refusal to observe ‘parda’ and her independent behavior constituted mental cruelty warranting divorce. The court emphasized that such actions do not qualify as cruelty under the law, particularly as both parties are educated professionals. While allegations of immoral relations lacked evidence, the court acknowledged the wife’s prolonged desertion and refusal to revive the marriage as valid grounds for divorce, ultimately granting the husband’s plea without requiring provisions for alimony, given their financial independence and adult child.
The Supreme Court quashed an FIR under Section 498A of the IPC against a brother-in-law while observing that a Court should consider whether the implication is an “over implication” to pressurise the family of the husband to yield to the wife’s demands. The Court observed that the allegations in the FIR against the brother-in-law were nothing but an exaggerated version invariably suggesting “over implication.” The Bench dismissed the complainant’s appeal challenging the quashing of proceedings against the brother-in-law by the Punjab and Haryana High Court.
Atul Subhash, a 34-year-old techie, died by suicide in his Bengaluru apartment, leaving a 24-page note accusing his wife and her family of harassment and alleging judicial corruption. His family revealed ongoing emotional distress from multiple legal cases filed against him. Bengaluru Police are investigating, summons issued for questioning.
The Calcutta High Court dismissed a Section 498A IPC case accusing a husband of cruelty, filed three years after the wife had left the matrimonial home. Justice Shampa (Dutt) Paul emphasized legal principles surrounding matrimonial disputes and noted the potential misuse of legal provisions in such cases.
The Supreme Court warned against the misuse of the law in marital dispute cases lodged by women against their husbands and families, saying that it cannot be used as a “tool to unleash personal vendetta”. A bench of Justices BV Nagarathna and N Kotiswar Singh on Tuesday (Dec 10) made the observation while setting aside a cruelty case filed against a man and his family under Section 498(A), which the Telangana High Court had refused to dismiss earlier.
A 34-year-old software engineer Atul Subhash committed suicide at his home in Marathahalli, Bengaluru, leaving a 24-page suicide note behind. He had pasted a sheet of paper with the words ‘Justice is Due’ while killing himself. In the video, Atul said that till now 120 court dates have been fixed and Atul himself had gone from Bangalore to Jaunpur 40 times. Apart from this, his parents and brother also have to visit the court.
Congress leader Navjot Singh Sidhu’s wife Navjot Kaur has been served a Rs 850 crore legal notice over the “traditional” cancer recovery claims made by Sidhu. The notice was issued by the Chhattisgarh Civil Society (CCS), and sought an explanation from her over the tall claims made by Sidhu regarding her cancer recovery diet. Kaur has been asked to produce evidence to support Sidhu’s arguments in seven days or else pay Rs 850 crore as compensation for the “misleading” claims.
The Supreme Court quashed an FIR under Section 498A of the IPC against a brother-in-law while observing that a Court should consider whether the implication is an “over implication” to pressurise the family of the husband to yield to the wife’s demands. The Court observed that the allegations in the FIR against the brother-in-law were nothing but an exaggerated version invariably suggesting “over implication.” The Bench dismissed the complainant’s appeal challenging the quashing of proceedings against the brother-in-law by the Punjab and Haryana High Court.
The Supreme Court Yesterday (Oct 21) noted that the tendency of over implication is reflected in a large number of cases filed alleging offence under Section 498A IPC and asked the Courts to be cautious about the same. The Court acquitted a man accused under Section 498A IPC while noting that only because he is the husband of guilty sister in law cannot be a ground to hold him guilty under the said offence in the absence of any specific material. The Court was hearing a Criminal Appeal against the decision of the High Court which partly allowed appellant’s appeal whereunder his conviction under Section 498-A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 was confirmed.
