The Supreme Court disposed of Sobhandeb Chattopadhyay’s plea after recording its expectation that the West Bengal Assembly Speaker would endeavour to decide the pending Tenth Schedule proceedings within three months of their filing.
“You had a fixed deposit as MLA, you tried for share market as MP, and now you lost the Fixed Deposit,” Justice Joymalya Bagchi remarked, as the Supreme Court dismissed Danam Nagender’s plea and upheld his disqualification as a Telangana MLA under the anti-defection law for contesting the Lok Sabha polls on a rival party’s […]
The Supreme Court has orally observed that the Lok Sabha Speaker is expected to expeditiously decide the Tenth Schedule disqualification petitions filed by Trinamool Congress leader Abhishek Banerjee against 20 party MPs who have sought to break away. Invoking the three-month norm laid down in Keisham Meghachandra Singh, the Court declined to issue directions but asked the Solicitor General to propose a timeline. The rebel MPs said they would file replies within four weeks.
The Supreme Court has described as a ‘red flag’ the three months taken so far by Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla to decide the disqualification petitions filed by Abhishek Banerjee against 20 Trinamool Congress MPs who broke away to join another party. Justice Joymalya Bagchi questioned why the matter had not been concluded given its repercussions, but the Court declined to fix a deadline, keeping the plea alive to seek a progress update.
Kapil Sibal argued in Kochi that the whip does not bind legislators in the United States, the United Kingdom or Europe as it does in India. The comparison needs qualifying, but the underlying point holds: India is unusual in attaching loss of the seat to a party direction, and every reform committee since 1990 has recommended narrowing it.
An independent MLA in Haryana switching sides three times gave Indian politics a phrase in 1967. Nearly sixty years, two failed Bills, one constitutional amendment and one repeal later, the same question is back before the Supreme Court. A look at how the Tenth Schedule was built and why each reform produced the next workaround.
Speaking at a talk in Kochi, Senior Advocate and Independent Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal questioned why the Supreme Court has not decided the correctness of the merger exception under Paragraph 4 of the Tenth Schedule since 2022, and argued that treating a legislature party merger as sufficient defeats the anti-defection law. The issue is pending before the Supreme Court.
Hearing the Shiv Sena disqualification case, the Supreme Court asked whether it could itself declare Shinde-faction MLAs disqualified or only set aside the Speaker’s order and remand it. New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday, hearing the Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena’s challenge to the Maharashtra Speaker’s refusal to disqualify Eknath Shinde faction MLAs, asked whether […]
Arguing the Shiv Sena disqualification case, Kapil Sibal told the Supreme Court the Maharashtra Speaker “distorted” the Tenth Schedule by treating the legislative party as the political party. New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Tuesday resumed hearing the Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena’s challenge to the Maharashtra Speaker’s refusal to disqualify MLAs of the Eknath Shinde […]
Hearing Uddhav Thackeray’s challenge to the ECI recognising the Shinde faction as the Shiv Sena, CJI Surya Kant said the rule letting the ECI decide symbol disputes first “may need a relook.” New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday heard extensive arguments in Uddhav Thackeray’s challenge to the Election Commission of India’s decision recognising the […]
