North vs South: Justice Nagarathna Raised Concerns Over Delimitation and Southern States’ Declining Population

Justice B.V. Nagarathna expressed concerns that delimitation based on population could diminish parliamentary representation for southern states, which are experiencing declining family sizes. During a hearing on surrogacy, she questioned the necessity for couples seeking to expand their families after natural conception, emphasizing personal choice and suggesting High Court alternatives.

Supreme Court Questions Parents Seeking Surrogacy After Failed IVF Attempts: “You Already Have One Child — Why Seek Another?”

NEW DELHI: Today, 9th May: The Supreme Court of India heard a writ petition filed by a group of parents seeking permission to opt for surrogacy after multiple failed IVF treatments. The matter came up before a bench comprising Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice S.C. Sharma.

Bombay HC: Grants Two Couples with Donor Eggs, Right to Surrogacy for Parenthood Under Article 14 of the Constitution

The Bombay High Court granted two couples the right to pursue surrogacy with donor eggs, challenging the 2023 amendment to surrogacy regulations. The ruling recognized the couples’ right to parenthood, emphasizing reproductive health as a fundamental liberty. The decision sets a precedent for couples seeking alternative paths to parenthood under Indian law.