MONTHLY RECAP FOR THE MONTH OF NOVEMBER 2024:

The Supreme Court made significant rulings on various constitutional and legal issues, including the non-challenge of statutes based on basic structure, necessity for official notifications for customs exemptions, and limitations on property rights. The Court reinforced principles of fairness, integrity in appointments, and guidelines against punitive demolitions while addressing social justice concerns.

“Supreme Court Institution is Greater Than Individual Judges”: Justice BV Nagarathna Objects CJI’s Remarks on Justice Krishna Iyer’s Community Resources Judgment

Today, On 5th November, Justice B.V. Nagarathna criticized Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud for his remarks about former judges, emphasizing that the Supreme Court’s institution transcends individual judges. She argued past judges should not be criticized for differing viewpoints, as their rulings aligned with the historical context of their times. Future judges should avoid unjust criticisms.

“Reason for the law (MHADA Act)?”: CJI Headed 9-Judge Bench | DAY-1 | Nature of Private Property

Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud on 23rd April noted the situation where tenants hold onto properties and landlords struggle with maintenance costs.The Supreme Court is reviewing a Maharashtra law aimed at acquiring old, unsafe buildings where tenants refuse to vacate and landlords lack funds for repairs.