Supreme Court: Agreement To Sell Confers No Title, Possession Suit Over Friends Colony Plot Fails

An agreement to sell confers no title without a registered sale deed, the Supreme Court has reiterated while upholding the dismissal of a 1975 suit for possession of a Friends Colony plot in Delhi. New Delhi: The Supreme Court has dismissed an appeal by the legal heirs of a 1950s allottee, holding that an agreement […]

MP High Court: Non-Nullity Objections To Arbitral Award Need Section 34 Petition, Not Section 47 CPC

Non-Nullity Objections To Arbitral Award belong in a petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and not in an application under Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure during execution, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has held; the objector keeps his remedy, as the time spent on the wrong route […]

Supreme Court Lists Waqf Amendment Act Challenge For November 4 As Petitioners Flag Irreversible Status Changes

The Waqf Amendment Act Challenge will be heard by the Supreme Court on November 4, after petitioners told a Bench led by CJI Surya Kant that waqf properties are changing status with consequences that may be irreversible.

Kerala High Court Rejects 50% Maintenance Deposit As Condition For Condoning Delay In Domestic Violence Appeal

The Kerala High Court has held that a 50% maintenance deposit as a condition for condoning delay cannot ordinarily be imposed on an appellant, since it fetters the statutory right of appeal. Kochi: The Kerala High Court has set aside a Sessions Court order that refused to condone delay in a domestic violence appeal because […]

Gujarat High Court Refuses To Condone 7-Year Delay In Filing Appeal, Rejects Non-Consensus And Covid Excuses

A 7-year delay in filing an appeal cannot be explained away by a pandemic that began three years after the judgment or by disagreement among co-owners, the Gujarat High Court has held while declining to condone it. Ahmedabad: The Gujarat High Court has refused to condone a delay of over seven years in filing an […]

MP High Court Slams ‘Misogynistic’ Reasoning That Elderly Men Cannot Rely On Younger Woman In Litigation

Calling it misogynistic reasoning with no basis on record, the Madhya Pradesh High Court has set aside an appellate court’s finding that elderly male members of a family could not have depended on a younger woman to file their appeal, and remanded the delay question for fresh decision. Gwalior: The Madhya Pradesh High Court has […]

Limitation Is Ordinarily A Mixed Question Of Law And Fact And Cannot Be Tried As A Preliminary Issue Once A Composite Trial Is Underway: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has clarified the scope of Order XIV Rule 2 of the CPC, holding that the question of limitation is ordinarily a mixed question of law and fact and cannot be tried as a preliminary issue of law, and that once a suit has proceeded to a composite trial with all issues framed, an issue cannot be detached and decided preliminarily. Restoring a 2013 suit to the trial court, the Court approved the Himachal Pradesh High Court’s Full Bench decision in Prithvi Raj Jhingta and clarified its earlier ruling in Sathyanath v. Sarojamani.

Electricity Dues Become ‘First Due’ Only When The Bill Is Issued: Supreme Court Dismisses Discom’s Rs 57.74 Lakh Demand Raised Nine Years Late

A UP distribution company demanded over Rs 57 lakh in minimum consumption charges in 2007 for an additional load it had offered, but never released, back in 1998. The Supreme Court dismissed the discom’s appeal, holding that electricity charges become ‘first due’ only when a bill is issued, and that a demand raised nine years later was barred by limitation.

Revocation of Probate Application Barred by Limitation if Parties Ignore Earlier Notice of Property Proceedings: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court held that probate revocation pleas under Section 263 of the Indian Succession Act are subject to limitation under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, ruling that parties cannot avoid statutory deadlines by ignoring constructive notice or failing to investigate facts a prudent person would examine.