Today, On 5th November, Justice B.V. Nagarathna criticized Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud for his remarks about former judges, emphasizing that the Supreme Court’s institution transcends individual judges. She argued past judges should not be criticized for differing viewpoints, as their rulings aligned with the historical context of their times. Future judges should avoid unjust criticisms.
Supreme Court judge Justice B.V. Nagarathna criticized the overstepping of roles by governors in India and their inactivity, reflecting poorly on the constitutional position of the governor. She emphasized the importance of fraternity and advocated for a focus on federalism, fundamental rights, and principled governance to strengthen Indian constitutionalism. She is set to become the Chief Justice of India in September 2027.
![[BREAKING] "States can Levy, Renew Demand for Tax on Mineral Rights Retrospectively From April 1, 2005": CJI Led 9-Judge Bench](https://i0.wp.com/lawchakra.in/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/image-36-2.png?resize=447%2C367&ssl=1)
Justice Nagarathna warned about the potential collapse of the federal system if states are allowed to tax minerals, citing disruption of power balance and governance structure. She argued that royalties should be considered taxes, highlighting risks of competition, increased costs, and negative economic impact. This could lead to decreased mining activity and strained foreign reserves.