Patna High Court Says Lawyer Cannot Sue Client For Defamation Over Removal From Bank Panel

“The right to practise is a right to appear when engaged; it is not a right to be engaged.” With that line, the Patna High Court has held that a lawyer cannot sue client for defamation merely because the client ended the professional engagement, rejecting an advocate’s Rs 25 lakh suit against State Bank of […]

Gujarat High Court Freezes Bankim Brahmbhatt’s Assets Worldwide In Rs 2,337 Crore International Fraud Suit

Thirty-six scheduled assets of Bankim Brahmbhatt and thirteen of his associate Mohit N. Rao can no longer be dealt with. The Gujarat High Court has frozen Bankim Brahmbhatt’s assets in India and abroad in a Rs 2,337 crore international fraud suit brought by seven US telecom companies he once ran, on allegations that are yet […]

Supreme Court Says Plaint Rejected Before Registration Must Be Recorded In Order IV Rule 2 Register

Can a plaint be rejected before registration, and who will ever know if it is? The Supreme Court has answered both: yes, it can, and every plaint rejected before registration must be recorded in the register maintained under Order IV Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as it restored a Cuddalore suit thrown […]

Supreme Court Upholds Bigamy Case Against UK Citizen Husband, Says Foreign Divorce Decree Cannot Shield Him

The Supreme Court held that a UK divorce decree granted on irretrievable breakdown of marriage cannot shield a husband married in India under Hindu rites from bigamy prosecution, while quashing the case against his parents and second wife.

Patna High Court Dismisses Partition Appeal, Says Suit Rested Only On Coincidence Of Fathers’ Names

A partition appeal that rested on “the similarity and coincidence of the fathers’ names” has failed in the Patna High Court, which found the claimed adoption unproved and the suit without a legal cause of action. Patna: The Patna High Court has dismissed a first appeal pending since 2006 against the rejection of a partition […]

Supreme Court Says Non-Party Can Appeal Consent Decree With Leave If It Prejudicially Affects Rights

A non-party can appeal consent decree with leave of the appellate court if it prejudicially affects a legally cognisable interest, the Supreme Court has held, explaining that the estoppel of a compromise binds only those who agreed to it. New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday, October 30, upheld a Gujarat High Court order granting […]

Allahabad HC: Decree Affirmed Up To Supreme Court Not Collusive, Directs Execution Within Three Months

The Allahabad High Court has refused to let the State of Uttar Pradesh reopen, as collusive, a 1977 decree for ejectment, rent and damages that was maintained in appeal, second appeal and before the Supreme Court, holding that the State contested the suits at every stage. Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has held that decrees […]

“Procedural Technicalities Shouldn’t Defeat Substantive Justice”: Karnataka HC Upholds Belated Plaint Amendment On Property Description

The Karnataka High Court has upheld a trial court’s order allowing a plaintiff to amend her plaint, holding that an amendment that only clarifies the existing cause of action, without changing the nature of the suit or setting up a new case, and which causes no prejudice to the other side, is to be allowed liberally to avoid multiplicity of litigation. The Court declined to interfere in its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227.

Supreme Court Rules Lawyers Cannot Surrender or Compromise Clients’ Property Rights Without Explicit Consent

The Supreme Court held that advocates cannot surrender or compromise a client’s substantive property rights without explicit authorisation. The Court ruled that a compromise decree based solely on a lawyer’s consent, without the client’s signature or approval, is legally unsustainable under the Civil Procedure Code.