Today (16th May): The Supreme Court ruled that Air India Limited ceased to be a state entity under Article 12 of the Constitution after its disinvestment and transfer to the Tata Group. The court dismissed appeals against the Bombay High Court’s verdict, stating that post-privatization, the company no longer fell under the court’s writ jurisdiction. The appellants were directed to seek alternative avenues for remedy.
More than 400 Short Service Commissioned Officers (SSCOs) are seeking post-retirement benefits, alleging discrimination and citing violations of their constitutional rights. They argue that they are denied benefits under various pension schemes and are left without financial support post-retirement. The case, acknowledged by the Supreme Court, could have significant implications for similar cases in various sectors.
Today (6th May): The Supreme Court of India upheld the minimum marks requirement in Bihar Judicial Services Examination interviews, ruling that it does not violate the right to equality under Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. The decision came in response to a plea from unsuccessful candidates, emphasizing the importance of maintaining fairness and transparency in the recruitment process.
The Madras High Court has directed the National Testing Agency to provide sanitary pads near toilets at NEET exam centers across India, in response to a 19-year-old petitioner’s medical needs. The ruling aims to ensure adequate facilities for female candidates and has been well-received, though concerns about monitoring during restroom breaks have been raised.
Debabrata Saikia, Leader of Opposition in Assam, has filed an Interlocutory Application before the Supreme Court On 13th March, challenging the regulations and Citizenship Amendment Act. Saikia argues that the act’s classification based on religion and country of origin violates constitutional principles and the Assam Accord. He requests a halt to the act’s implementation, citing potential harm and constitutionality violations.
Asaram Bapu, a controversial spiritual leader, filed a Special Leave Petition with the Rajasthan High Court seeking urgent medical treatment at a specific hospital due to severe health issues. Despite facing legal challenges, his plea emphasizes his fundamental right to proper medical care, as his age and health conditions pose a significant risk in prison.
On 4th March: The Supreme Court of India has requested a government response to allegations of gender bias in the promotions of female army officers. Thirty women officers filed a contempt petition citing disparities in their promotion process compared to male counterparts. The plea challenges a selection board recommending only eight women officers for promotion against 42 available slots, despite a previous directive for fair and transparent selection processes.
The Supreme Court emphasized the inclusion of women in defense services, responding to a petition by a female Coast Guard officer seeking a permanent commission. The judges criticized the Coast Guard’s exclusion of women compared to the Army and Navy, citing gender equality and the Babita Punia judgment. The court requested a formal response from the Centre and set a follow-up hearing for March 1.
The Delhi High Court has clarified that the right to adopt children is not a fundamental right and upheld restrictions on adopting a “normal child” for parents who already have two children. This decision supports amendments to the Adoption Rules, aiming to encourage the adoption of children with special needs and applies the changes retroactively but not retrospectively.
The Bombay High Court granted two couples the right to pursue surrogacy with donor eggs, challenging the 2023 amendment to surrogacy regulations. The ruling recognized the couples’ right to parenthood, emphasizing reproductive health as a fundamental liberty. The decision sets a precedent for couples seeking alternative paths to parenthood under Indian law.
