As of now, the Supreme Court has a total of 54 cases pending before its Constitution Benches. These cases are divided among different compositions of the benches
The Supreme Court of India is currently grappling with a significant backlog of cases awaiting adjudication before its Constitution Benches. Recent data presented in Parliament sheds light on the magnitude of pending cases and the pace at which they are being resolved, revealing a concerning trend in the judiciary’s ability to manage its caseload efficiently.
The Pending Caseload
As of now, the Supreme Court has a total of 54 cases pending before its Constitution Benches. These cases are divided among different compositions of the benches, with 38 cases requiring the attention of five-judge benches, 9 cases awaiting the deliberation of seven-judge benches, and 7 cases poised for nine-judge benches. This distribution underscores the complexity and significance of the matters at hand, which necessitate the involvement of larger benches for a comprehensive adjudication process.
Disposal Rate and Historical Context
Between the years 2020 and 2023, the Supreme Court has managed to dispose of only 25 Constitution Bench cases. This figure is indicative of the challenges faced by the Court in keeping up with its workload. Since its inception in 1950, the Supreme Court has resolved a total of 2,188 Constitution Bench cases. A closer examination of the decade-wise disposal rates reveals that the initial decade (1950-1959) saw the highest number of disposals, with 956 cases being resolved. This period of high productivity contrasts sharply with the current pace of case resolution, highlighting a growing backlog that merits urgent attention.
Insights from Parliament
The details of the pending and disposed cases were brought to light in response to a query raised in Parliament. Union Minister of State (independent charge) for Law & Justice, Arjun Ram Meghwal, provided these insights in response to questions posed by Alappuzha Lok Sabha MP and Advocate AM Ariff. Ariff’s inquiry sought detailed data on the backlog before various Constitution Benches of the Supreme Court, alongside a decade-wise breakdown of cases heard and disposed of since the Court’s establishment.
Implications and the Path Forward
The accumulation of pending cases before the Supreme Court’s Constitution Benches is more than a mere statistic; it signifies a critical bottleneck in the delivery of justice. Each unresolved case represents a question of constitutional importance that awaits a definitive resolution, affecting the legal landscape and potentially the lives of countless individuals.
To address this growing backlog, there is a pressing need for strategic reforms aimed at enhancing the Court’s efficiency. These could include the expansion of the judiciary, the adoption of advanced legal technologies, and the streamlining of procedural aspects to expedite case handling. Moreover, fostering a collaborative approach between the judiciary, the legal community, and the government could pave the way for innovative solutions that ensure timely justice delivery.
As the Supreme Court continues to navigate through its extensive caseload, the focus must remain on upholding the principles of justice and constitutional integrity. The resolution of pending Constitution Bench cases is not just a matter of reducing numbers but a fundamental requirement for the sustenance of democracy and the rule of law in India.
READ MORE: LOK SABHA QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS